Samuel, Thirty-Four, London
Profession Communications expert
Political affiliation Was a Labour party member from the age of 16, resigned three months ago and joined the Green party. Intends to vote Green in future.
Interesting tidbit Wrote a light-hearted book detailing the canine companions of philosophers.
Cat, 24, London
Profession Formerly worked supporting homeless individuals in a hospital setting.
Political affiliation Her electoral history includes a tactical Liberal Democrat vote followed by a Green vote.
Interesting tidbit When Catrina was sent home from university during Covid, she worked in a mortuary, then used that experience for her dissertation.
For starters
Catrina He was incredibly smiley, very bubbly and effervescent. He was wearing a fetching pink suit, which was his wedding suit.
Samuel I thought she was great. She’d just got back from four months trekking the Silk Road, I was slightly jealous. She was very intellectually curious, obviously a good talker. The conversation flowed.
Catrina It was a bit of a cultural hodgepodge, the menu, German but also Korean – I had a hotdog for my main, we also had an oyster. We had a few cocktails as well.
Samuel My order consisted of a lobster roll, an oyster, and finished with a Korean doughnut.
Key Discussion
Catrina The basis for my stance on high immigration levels is the recent net migration statistic. From a worldwide perspective, I believe it's problematic for the UK to recruit skilled professionals from regions experiencing their own talent drains, such as West Africa.
Samuel It’s not that Catrina’s unwelcoming or racist; it’s more that she was concerned that by allowing a vacuum in our system, which needs doctors etc to come and work for us, we were creating a brain drain elsewhere. I said it reminded me of that Stewart Lee anti-Ukip sketch: “I think the brightest and best should stay in Bulgaria”. She said that was her favourite sketch.
Catrina The international student cohort contributes heavily to net migration. Universities, driven by economics, accept them readily. I value diversity deeply, but the present model appears unsustainable.
Samuel I grasped her argument. However, the draw of our world-class universities is powerful. The issue isn't the students themselves, but a system that prioritises revenue over societal good.
Common Ground
Catrina On so-called 'woke' culture, I believe it has overreached. My criticism is that it often focuses too much on personal behaviour rather than systemic change. Problems like racism are embedded in society; making it purely individual can deter people from the conversation.
Samuel Our thoughts aligned with commentators who see 'wokeness' as a source of division on the left. My philosophy is more straightforward: lead with empathy and respect in all human interactions.
For afters
Catrina Sam was more optimistic than me about the potential for AI and technology. I think social media is really complicating our politics and diminishing people’s quality of life.
Samuel I can't deny the negative spiral social media can create. However, I focus on technology's historical trajectory—centuries of innovation driven by our innate curiosity and need for connection. AI, for instance, is revolutionising medical diagnostics like cancer screening.
Parting Thoughts
Catrina We exchanged numbers. He was a really nice man, I’d love to catch up with him again.
Samuel She presented me with a Kazakh postcard showing a stunning mural on an abandoned building. The beauty of it struck me. It inspired a moment of self-reflection about bringing more beauty into the world.