Throughout the opening hour, Newcastle's German forward cut an extremely isolated in the opposition box. A poor showing took a disastrous turn not long after the restart when he unintentionally guided a cross beyond his own goalkeeper from close range.
Woltemade’s embarrassing own goal emerged as the accidental winning goal in a fixture high on full-blooded aggression but lacking in moments of real quality.
Upon his substitution, the home supporters offered the visibly deflated 23-year-old a sarcastic ovation. A fan favourite until that moment, Woltemade has now achieved the dubious honour of winning a lasting, deeply sardonic place in local derby history.
A City Steeped in Contempt
It may have been the biggest show in town, the first Premier League derby between these clubs in almost a decade had competition from local drama taking place on the weekend. A short distance from the football ground, the matinee performance of Sleeping Beauty was beginning at the Empire Theatre.
The sleeping princess would have had to do remarkably well to have slept through the febrile, raw cacophony that rolled across town from the adjacent stadium. The players took to the pitch beneath a tifo featuring a ferocious Sunderland mascot with teeth bared and talons ready.
A Nervous Start from the Visitors
Newcastle cowered accordingly and their marked tentativeness was all too apparent in an first half devoid of great effect. Isolated in attack, the striker was given an early inkling this might not be his day when a teammate gave him a harsh and verbal rebuke for a wayward ball.
As with many intense derby matches, the deep-seated animosity between the supporters is said to be unmatched in its ferocity. On occasion during a fractured opening period, the pitch was reminiscent of a battlefield with bodies falling to the deck with gusto.
A Mixed Day for Sunderland
An auspicious occasion for Sunderland after an prolonged exile from the top flight was overshadowed by sad news. News of club legend Gary Rowell's passing after a prolonged sickness had spread through the town.
Before kick-off, a heartfelt and extended tribute was paid to the ex-player with a standing ovation from the crowd.
Regarding their approach and personnel, today's version of Sunderland bears little resemblance to the side contemptuously swatted aside in a cup tie last year. Perhaps a blessing in disguise, that grim day ultimately led to a well-funded summer revival.
A Fortress Venue and a Chastening Loss
In recent years, Newcastle have experienced their own rise to prominence. Yet, they have found it difficult away from home in this campaign. As defeats go, this was as painful and sobering as they get.
They have now failed to beat Sunderland in nine consecutive fixtures. This reverse was their fourth on the spin at the Stadium of Light, a fortress where the home mood could hardly be more upbeat.